- 10 Steps to Busting Your Brick Wall
- Step One: Define the Brick Wall
- Step Two: Create a Timeline
- Step Three: Evaluate the Evidence
- Step Four: Search for New Evidence
- Step Five: Resolve Conflicts
- Step Six: Search for Social History
- Step Seven: Collateral Relatives
- Step Eight: Friends, Neighbours and Acquaintances (FAN)
- Step Ten: DNA Research
- Step Nine: Crowd Source the Problem
Now that we’ve defined our brick wall, created a timeline, evaluated our existing evidence, searched for new evidence, resolved conflicts, searched for social history and searched for collateral relatives, the next step in the Busting Your Brick Wall Challenge will be to research the friends, neighbours and acquaintances.
Recommended by an Expert
The FAN principal, or cluster research, to break through brick walls is highly recommended by Elizabeth Shown Mills as a key strategy.
Smiths and Jones
One of the most common reasons for hitting a brick wall in your family history research is the problem I’ve run into with my Brown family. It isn’t that I can’t find George Brown born in Sheffield in about 1815. It is that there are far too many George Browns born in Sheffield in about 1815!
Those of us with common surnames such as Smith, Jones, Brown, Walker, Taylor and so on, often find ourselves with far too many candidates for the ancestor we’re searching for.
Even with less common surnames, our ancestors often followed naming traditions such as that of naming the oldest child after a grandparent, resulting in five men named “Richard Wearne” or a half dozen women named “Sarah Hilliers”, all related, all of similar ages and all living in the same place.
How are we to sort them all out?
We turn to their friends, neighbours and acquaintances. We turn to their FAN club.
Follow the FAN: Friends, Neighbours and Acquaintances
Spending hours, days or even weeks researching the people in your ancestor’s life might seem like time that could be better spent, but nothing could be further from the truth. Although it might seem like the long way around, sometimes these people will lead us back to our ancestor in surprising ways.
On 26 July 1876, my great-grandparents, William and Emily Brown, had their oldest two sons, Joseph and Arthur, baptized at St. Philips Church in Sheffield. On the same day, George and Mary Draycott had their two oldest sons, Arthur and Frank, baptized in the same church. What did these two events have in common in addition to the date? Both couples lived at Court 2, Robert Street in Sheffield. Clearly the Draycotts and Browns were close neighbours and I should do more research on the Draycott family to see how long the friendship goes back and to see if their lives intersect at other places.
When my third great-grandmother, Rebecca Storey, died on 29 September 1867 at the age of 79, I found that the death certificate mentioned ‘Mary Ann Perkins present at the death 20 Pier Street Ryde’. Since Rebecca died while living in the home of her widowed daughter Caroline Leek, I wondered who Mary Ann Perkins was and why she had been present at the death. The name sounded familiar though and a careful search showed that at the time of the 1851 census when the widowed Rebecca was 62 years old and running a green grocery on Monckton Street, her neighbour was none other than Marianne Perkins, also a widow, who ran a butcher shop. Clearly the two women had something in common and must have become fast friends. Had I been unsure about whether I had the correct death for Rebecca Storey, finding Marianne Perkins’ name on the death certificate would have helped me to confirm it.
For many years, I searched for the parents of my fifth great-grandfather, William Bulmer. When he married Mary Rudd in 1773 in Bolton-on-Swale, the marriage record said that William Bulmer was ‘of the parish of Langton but I could find no record of his birth or baptism. I did not know who his parents were. It was not until much, much later that I found a land deed that mentioned William’s maternal grandfather, John Harker when I was finally able to put it all together and move back several more generations. Had I paid more attention to the records I already had, I would have seen that when William Bulmer purchased Streetlam farm in 1787, the transfer of the deed was witnessed by William Harker of Langton and I might have made the connection much sooner. I’m still not sure where William Harker fits into the family but it seems quite likely that he wasn’t just a witness but was probably family. Make sure you research the witnesses of any documents that you find. Chances are, the witnesses were close to the person featured in the document.
Researching Friends, Neighbours and Acquaintances on My Brick Wall
I have not yet thoroughly researched the FAN club for my brick wall Brown family but there are many people lurking on the periphery of George and Ann Brown’s lives. It could be that one of them holds the key to the mystery. If this step leads me closer to breaking through my brick wall, I will come back and update this post.
I have been developing the FAN Club of an ancestor who has no obvious direct family. To determine where he was born, the FAN members I know of reveal precious little about him. Documents involving some of his sons show this man was born in Pennsylvania, while documents involving his daughters say he was born in Ireland. My question is, how do you keep straight and organize the multiple documents you have to research about these FAN Club people? What should get priority in your research time? Could you blog about how you do the mechanics of FAN research? How do you keep track of it all?
I generally keep track of my fan research in one of two ways, depending on the scope. For the example I mentioned in this blog post, I actually added the family to my own genealogy database and researched them like I would any other related family. It was clear that there was a close relation between these families over a long period of time, whether I eventually found they were related by blood or marriage or not. In other cases, I’ve done a separate ‘scratch’ tree, sometimes with my genealogy software and sometimes as a private ‘scratch’ tree on Ancestry (I make it private and unsearchable in this case as I don’t want other researchers finding it and thinking we are related.)
As for prioritization, I wish I could say I set priorities. I normally just chase every lead and follow a lot of false trails. Just when I begin to get discouraged, however, I find something worthwhile and the cycle begins again!